Are you ready for this? Are you ready for the best frosting ever? My new Pistachio Pudding Buttercream Frosting is a dream frosting for pistachio lovers!!!
Pistachio Pudding Buttercream Frosting

Yes, I had a pistachio pudding problem. You know this, I know this. We're good.

So of course, when I whipped up my Homemade Pistachio Pudding Cake, I knew that there wasn't going to be any plain frosting on top of that beauty. Nuh-uh. We were going full-bore, pedal to the metal, kick the tires and light the fires pistachio overload.

Now this recipe took me a while to get it right. There's a certain method you have to use, so please follow my instructions carefully. If not, you end up with a gritty icing.

OUR LATEST VIDEOS

I don't want to see you have any temper tantrums like I did. I swear, I'm in the wrong business some days. When I ruined my first batch of icing, the air was blue, smoke was coming out of my ears and I was just mad. This is why I do my baking while the kids are at school. Mama has a potty mouth when she ruins recipes.

But hey, that's what happens when you develop recipes. Sometimes you have enough knowledge that you nail it every time and others you have to completely fubar the method only to learn a lesson and do it differently next time.

I'll try to remember I said that next time I'm having a temper tantrum over wasted ingredients.

When you use this buttercream icing, make sure that you have some fresh pistachios to smash up and scatter over the top of the cake. It is just perfect when you do.

Oh and salted pistachios are the best of course! Add that little zip of salt to this via the butter in the icing and the pistachios and it seriously takes it over the top!

Pistachio Pudding Buttercream Frosting

There are other pistachio pudding icing recipes that use Cool Whip and pudding mix. I so wasn't having any of that. I needed a pistachio pudding frosting that was based on my famous Best Buttercream Icing Ever recipe. I wanted something buttery and good and eat-off-the-spoon amazing.

Now this is an icing that you can literally eat off the spoon, it's so evil. The whole cake is evil!

I like evil.

Happy baking everyone!

Make sure to check out all of my other buttercream frosting recipes!:

Lemon Buttercream Frosting

Pistachio Pudding Buttercream Frosting

Candy Bar Buttercream Frosting

How to Make Peppermint Buttercream Frosting

 

Love you more than pistachio pudding,

Karlynn

Pistachio Pudding Buttercream frosting, a gorgeous, melt in your mouth buttercream icing that's flavored with pistachio pudding. To.Die.For.

 

3.79 from 38 votes
Pistachio Buttercream Frosting
Prep Time
5 mins
Cook Time
4 hrs 21 mins
 
Decadent pistachio pudding buttercream frosting! This delicious frosting combines my two favorite foods.
Course: icing
Servings: 4 cups
Author: Karlynn Johnston
Ingredients
  • 1/2 cup salted butter
  • 1/2 cup milk
  • 3 tbsp instant pistachio pudding powder
  • 2 - 2 1/2 cups powdered sugar
Instructions
  1. Using the paddle attachment on a stand mixer, cream the butter until light and fluffy.
  2. In a measuring cup, combine the milk and the pudding mix until it's completely dissolved. If you do not dissolve it all at this point, you will have gritty icing!
  3. Beat the pudding mixture into the butter completely.
  4. Add in the powdered sugar, half a cup at a time, beating in completely.
  5. Chill the icing for approximately 20 minutes, to allow the jello and the butter to set more completely.
  6. Use to ice cakes and cupcakes.
  7. Yield: Approximately 1 1/2 cups of icing. This will frost one standard sized bundt cake perfectly.
Nutrition Facts
Pistachio Buttercream Frosting
Amount Per Serving (1 g)
Calories 0
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.
130
Author

Hey guys, I'm Karlynn! Welcome to The Kitchen Magpie, my website full of family friendly recipes, cocktails & homesteading tales of chickens & cows from the family farm! Make sure to check out my bestselling cookbook, Flapper Pie & a Blue Prairie Sky ,stay tuned for info on my second cookbook!

26 Comments

  1. I just bakgot d this gorgeous cake and it came out perfectly!
    However, I won’t be able to frost the cake for 24 hrs….so I have to questions:
    Can I make the frosting and frost the cake tomorrow before the party or…..
    Can I make the frosting right now, refrigerate it until tomorrow and frost it then? (Once it’s come to room temp, right?)

  2. Dominick Auci Reply

    This was a truly amazing cake…truly delicious and visually striking. I made a simpler icing, which really gives me a ton of ideas.. I just mixed a box of Jello Brand Pistachio pudding with 8 oz of Cool Whip. Simple.. and delicious.

    Thanks for this Karlynn!

  3. It took me forever to find this but I’m sure glad I kept looking. The best frosting recipe I have ever made by far. Thank you so much

    • I forgot to show my star rating but I give you all the stars you can get 😉

  4. This all sounds good but I am looking for a cake from scratch and with homemade pudding mix. I don’t like the artificial flavor in packaged pudding. Anyone have a recipe where the “whole cake is from scratch”. ??

  5. Gramma Kaye Reply

    HI Karlynn, I’m wondering if this pistachio butter cream is ok for piping. Nothing delicate, just some big swirls with a medium or large star tip (shamrocks for St Pat’s day). Thanks in advance.

  6. Hey! Could I use this as a filling for macarons? Or would the moisture content be too high?

  7. boldtruth11 Reply

    The buttercream got pretty gluey. Wish they didnt make commercially prepared products so salty (e.g., pudding). i used unsalted butter and it was still too salty thanks to the pudding.

  8. I really had to play with this buttercream to get it to work. I’m a very experienced baker and I was testing it to potentially use on a pistachio wedding cake, which definitely calls for a good smooth buttercream. I doubled the recipe and I’m doing so, the buttercream broke. So after sitting it in an ice bath in the fridge for about an hour, I still just couldn’t get anything but a soupy mess. It ended up taking about 4 times the recommended sugar to get this to a true buttercream consistency that you can actually frost a wedding cake with. It’s got a great flavor, but it definitely requires some playing with if you’re doubling the recipe.

  9. I was a bit short on powdered sugar so I just put the whole box of pudding mix in the frosting.  It came out super yummy and people commented on how much pistachio flavor they had…..then again, I rolled the tops in crushed pistachios, too.

    • Please share your exact recipe. I can’t wait to try it this way.

  10. muscle3332007 Reply

    I love this cake recipe! I reduced the butter to 1 stick (8 T). I omitted the oil and salt. I used 2 tsp baking powder. It came out superb in muffin tins!!! I like my cupcakes small and find they are less likely to sink if I use smaller amounts of batter like muffin pans instead of cupcake pans.

    I used traditional butter cream icing but will try the pistachio icing next time. 

    Thankyou for this recipe as the internet is full of Watergate cake recipes that use boxed cake mixes but few for scratch recipes.

    • thekitchenmagpie Reply

      muscle3332007 Yes, I really wanted a from scratch cake!

    • You have me lost , it calls for 1 stick of butter also there is no oil or salt. I think your on the wrong recipe. This is just for frosting

  11. Hi

    Did you have to buy another box of pistachio pudding mix or did you save 3 tablespoons of the mix from the cake recipe.

    • muscle3332007 Reply

      @Jackie You need 2 boxes because 3 tablespoons is like half the box of pudding mix. 

  12. My cake came out high and then sank like a rock. The frosting was not a hit. Liked taste of the cake before it sank ( I snuck a piece of the overhanging part) Frosting was not a hit at all!.

  13. Does this need to be refrigerated? I would love to make it, but the cottage I’m taking it to doesn’t have fridge space

    • @Lauran  My guess is it would be fine unrefrigerated for a couple of days as long as it is fairly well sealed in a container.

  14. Everything about this cake and the buttercream icing is outstanding. It’s just awesome!!!!

  15. linda prout Reply

    would have loved to make your pistachio buttercream icing, but we don’t have the mixes you use in America. any ideas for an alternative

Write A Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.