This post may contain affiliate links. See my privacy policy for details.

Brownie Trifle

Remember my tendency to giggle when I have a super fabulous dessert recipe that I can’t wait to share with you? Well, this baby had me giggling all day long yesterday. We had a couple over last night for dinner and I had to come up with a new dessert recipe. In fact, all of the recipes I made last night were new creations since one of the duo coming over was a food blogger as well. I figured that if anyone would forgive a new recipe mistake, it would be him.

My advice to you? Have a casual dinner party right after Halloween and make this. I used up SO MUCH candy making this and sent home leftovers with my guests. Winner winner dessert for dinner!

It’s hard to gauge how much candy you need, but I would aim for about 3 cups of chopped chocolate bars, M&M’s, basically anything that has chocolate will be good. Avoid the other taffy’s, gummies etc as they will not work out well in this.


All you need is Halloween chocolates, a baked up 9×13 brownie, chocolate pudding and whipping cream.

Brownie Trifle

You can either use a box recipe to make things faster or my Best Brownies Ever recipe. Make sure to cook it in a 9×13 pan, we are looking for thin, chewy brownies.

Slice the brownies into three, one part for each layer.

Brownie Trifle

For the pudding, you can make my Homemade Skim Milk Chocolate Pudding recipe. It was amazing and not too sweet. If you want to save time again, use a boxed one but the taste will not be as good as homemade! Also, my recipe makes enough to have one cup of pudding per layer and you won’t get that with a boxed mix.

This pudding is the bomb. Seriously.

Brownie Trifle

Whip three cups of whipping cream with your mixer, adding in one tbsp of sugar to sweeten it just a little bit.

Start with a layer of brownies all chopped up, one cup of chocolate pudding, one cup of whipped cream then one cup of chopped up Halloween candy. Repeat all these layers until you end with Halloween candy. You should have one cup of whipped cream left, so use that on the very top.

Then cut up as many more chocolate bars as you want to decorate the top.

Brownie TrifleIt’s so awe inspiring.

So sugar laden.


So incredibly tasty.

Make it, eat one serving then send it away. You’re going to have to.

Brownie Trifle

My mistake was making this for a dinner party of only four people (plus the kids had some as well). This is perfect for a large get together, as I would guess it would serve around 16 people and that’s giving them large servings! However, I had my Tupperware ready and sent home a good quarter of this with our guests.

Brownie Trifle

If you aren’t having any guests over soon, try to set a large amount of these aside and keep it for your next event. I know, it’s hard not to snack on those little devilish chocolate bars when they are in the house, they are like a siren song calling to you.

I’m having a hard time getting over this deliciousness and moving on to creating another recipe. I just want to wallow in it’s awesomeness a little more.


Speaking of which, which candy is your siren call? Which one can’t you resist? I am infamous for my love of Coffee Crisp, which is a chocolate bar that’s available here in Canada but not the States.

What’s yours? Snickers? Milky Way? Licorice?

Thanks for stopping in!




Leftover Halloween Candy Brownie Trifle
Prep Time
20 mins
Cook Time
5 mins
Total Time
25 mins
Decadent leftover Halloween Candy brownie trifle, one seriously delicious chocolate dessert!
Course: Dessert
Cuisine: Trife
Servings: 16
Author: Karlynn Johnston
  • one brownie recipe baked ( 9x13 inch ) pan boxed mix is finemy homemade chocolate pudding recipe assorted Halloween chocolate bars and candy for the topping
  • 3 cups chopped up Halloween chocolate bars
  • 3 cups whipping cream
  • 1 tbsp white sugar
Homemade Chocolate Pudding Recipe
  1. Slice the entire brownie pan into thirds, one part for each layer.Make the chocolate pudding and cool. It doesn't have to set completely, just be cool enough that it won't melt the chocolate.Whip the three cups of whipping cream and one tbsp of white sugar in your mixer until the whipped cream is light and fluffy.Start with a layer of brownies (one third of the pan, all chopped up) then spread on top of the brownies one cup of chocolate pudding, then one cup of whipped cream then one cup of chopped up Halloween candy. Repeat all these layers until you end with Halloween candy. You should have one cup of whipped cream left, so use that on the very top.Chop up as many Halloween chocolate bars as you would like to garnish the top.Refrigerate for at least 6 hours. If you like everything very soft, refrigerate overnight. If you like a little bit of "chew" in your trifle, you can prep it a mere three hours ahead.
Nutrition Facts
Leftover Halloween Candy Brownie Trifle
Amount Per Serving (16 g)
Calories 0
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.



Hey guys, I'm Karlynn! Welcome to The Kitchen Magpie, my website full of family friendly recipes, cocktails & homesteading tales of chickens & cows from the family farm! Make sure to check out my bestselling cookbook, Flapper Pie & a Blue Prairie Sky ,stay tuned for info on my second cookbook!


  1. This was great. Made it for a contest at work and won. 🙂


  2. Maggie_Shay Reply

    This looks absolute delish.. Cant wait til next Halloween ;p

  3. Maggie_Shay Reply

    This looks absolute delish.. Cant wait til next Halloween ;p jk. I may have to go buy some choclate bars and Smarties.. And my siren call is Snickers lol.. and Those green chewy frogs.. Love your recipes btw

Write A Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Send this to a friend